- Director:Mike Mariano
- Writer:Gregory Thomas Garcia,Vali Chandrasekaran
- Cast:Jason Lee,Ethan Suplee,Jaime Pressly
Earl tries to help his old babysitter, whom he got pregnant by poking holes in her condom, by whipping her deadbeat son into shape. However, Randy gets mad at Earl when he recognizes the similarities between the man and himself.
|Episode cast overview, first billed only:|
|Jason Lee||-||Earl Hickey|
|Ethan Suplee||-||Randy Hickey|
|Jaime Pressly||-||Joy Turner|
|Eddie Steeples||-||Darnell Turner|
|Faith Ford||-||Rachel McGann|
|Noah Crawford||-||Young Earl|
|Paul Eiding||-||Business Man|
|DeeDee Rescher||-||Homeless Woman (as Dee Dee Rescher)|
|Brie Gabrielle||-||Teenage Rachel McGann|
|Michael Nardelli||-||Teenage Daniel|
|Ryan Armstrong||-||Young Randy|
Earl Got the Babysitter Pregnant (2005–2009)
It is revealed that Randy is 31.
Mr. Turtle's first name is Sidney, as can be seen in the scene when Darnell was about to bury the replacement Joy gave him.